Plus des Pitchers

Behold the board at the end of the 10/26 class. As usual, much of it was erased and then refilled. This photo corresponds to the lesson plan as it runs from settling down in Canaan through the anointing of David. I’m not going to discuss everything we covered, just what is on the board.

1. The Ark of the Covenant.  Some review of last week’s class. The Glory Cloud/ Shekhinah is introduced, which settles on/ overshadows/ dwells in the Ark and Meeting Tent. At the far left a sketch of Moses atop Sinai  under the Glory Cloud/ Shekhinah has been erased. Tent drawing to left illustrates how the Glory Cloud overshadowed the Tent during the 40 years in the desert, and moved away when it was time to pull up stakes. Overshadowing implies protection. (future connections to Elijah & Elisha, the Holy Spirit & Mary.)

2. Review of atonement, forgiveness, and  Levitical sacrifice is followed by the question, “Could good Israelites who had their sins forgiven & atoned for by the sacrificial system go to Heaven?” If not, then where did they go? (future connection: Jesus descended into “Hell.”)

3. The ritual mixing of cleansing water and atoning blood is introduced (Lev 14): “This shall be the law of the leper for the day of his cleansing. He shall be brought to the priest; 3 and the priest shall go out of the camp, and the priest shall make an examination. Then, if the leprous disease is healed in the leper, 4 the priest shall command them to take for him who is to be cleansed two living clean birds and cedarwood and scarlet stuff and hyssop; 5 and the priest shall command them to kill one of the birds in an earthen vessel over running water. 6 He shall take the living bird with the cedarwood and the scarlet stuff and the hyssop, and dip them and the living bird in the blood of the bird that was killed over the running water; 7 and he shall sprinkle it seven times upon him who is to be cleansed of leprosy…” (future connections to the Crucifixion and Baptism)

4. The Israelites settle down in Canaan. God dwells in the Meeting Tent at Shiloh. I add Eli sitting on his stool to the left while his corrupt sons profane the Dwelling.

5. Review of Samson introduces the word Nazirite, someone who is dedicated and separated to fully serve God. (future connection to John the Baptist, priests and nuns) Samuel’s story follows Samson’s, including Samuel being called by God 3 times and responding in the affirmative 3 times, which makes an oral contract. (future connections to Elijah & Elisha, Jesus & Peter)

6. Connecting the past to the present. A reminder that the Israelites still fight with their neighbors over the Promised Land.

7. Israel’s enemies worshiped an assortment of baby-eating false gods, yet they were also afraid of the God of Israel: “Israel went out to battle against the Philistines….Israel was defeated by the Philistines, who slew about four thousand men on the field of battle. 3 And when the troops came to the camp, the elders of Israel said, “Why has the LORD put us to rout today before the Philistines? Let us bring the ark of the covenant of the LORD here from Shiloh, that he may come among us and save us from the power of our enemies….the Philistines were afraid; for they said, “A god has come into the camp.” And they said, “Woe to us! For nothing like this has happened before. 8 Woe to us! Who can deliver us from the power of these mighty gods? These are the gods who smote the Egyptians with every sort of plague in the wilderness.” (1Sam 4)

Sinful Israel is defeated, Eli & sons die. The Ark is captured, but due to plagues including my favorite plague, hemorrhoids, the Ark is returned to Israel. But the LORD never dwells again in Shiloh, which remains desolate. (future connections to Jeremiah, the Temple, and Jesus)

8. Confronted with the prospect of being misgoverned by Samuel’s no-good sons, Israel insists on a king after Samuel. Samuel picks Saul, who as we see from the picture is tall and handsome.

9. Saul has his problems; God sends Samuel out to secretly anoint a new king: David. We act out the anointing process. The kids learn the common meaning of Messiah, Christos, and Anointed One. Some etymologically related words are discussed, especially chrism and msha, the Egyptian word for crocodile, whose oil was used to anoint Pharaoh. (lots of connections to all this)

10. The Gingerbread Man represents the unity of Body and Soul. This had to do with the hypocritical behavior of Eli & Sons. I usually draw him when the issue of Faith and Works comes up. The arrow from the body back to the soul indicates that one’s works reflect one’s inward disposition; so if your works oppose your faith, then you probably don’t really believe. (connects to constant theme of Faith & Works)

Catechists, never forget the words of St. Francis of Assisi, Petter of Squirrels: “Preach the Gospel at all times; when necessary, draw pictures.”

Review – Footprints of God: David and Solomon

Steve Ray combines biblical archaeology, Catholic apologetics, and wacky humor to teach viewers of his “Footprints of God” video series about the Bible in an engaging, memorable way. David and Solomon: Expanding the Kingdom is the sixth installment of the series, and focuses on showing how the lives of these two kings of Israel prefigured the life and teachings of Christ.

David and Solomon Expanding the KingdomThe video primarily focuses on the life of David, from his humble beginnings as a shepherd to his rise to the greatest king of Israel. Ray shows us both the accomplishments and the failings of this larger-than-life figure, helping us to understand how he remained a heroic leader despite his serious misdeeds. Ray takes us on a tour of the actual sites in the Holy Land where significant events occurred, explaining the events that led the people of Israel to demand that God give them a king and how this led to the height of their power before ultimately leading to their exile. He emphasizes God’s covenant with David and how it came to be fulfilled by Jesus.

Ray also leads us through the life of Solomon, again drawing parallels between events in his life and the life of Jesus. He draws upon rabbinic tradition to break open the prophecies and sayings about the kings of Israel and to explain their deeper symbolism.

As with the other videos in the series, the ultimate focus is on how the stories of the Old Testament prefigure and help us better understand Jesus. This interpretation is in keeping with centuries of Catholic biblical exegesis and draws the viewer in as the Bible is “decoded.”

Ray’s enthusiasm is what keeps us engaged in his detailed explanations of Biblical archaelogy and history, and he uses puns and vivid metaphors to help us remember key points. As a result, his video is both educational for those already familiar with the Scriptural passages he discusses, and easily understood by those who know little about David and Solomon. I’ve used this and other videos in a classroom setting with high school students and found them to be an effective, memorable tool for introducing kids to sacred Scripture.

You can purchase this DVD here

I wrote this review of David and Solomon Expanding the Kingdom for the free Catholic Book review program, created by Aquinas and More Catholic Goods, your source for Baptism Gifts and Oplatki Christmas Wafers.
Tiber River is the first Catholic book review site, started in 2000 to help you make informed decisions about Catholic book purchases.
I receive free product samples as compensation for writing reviews for Tiber River.

Review: 5 Minutes with Christ: Spiritual Nourishment for Busy Teachers

Teaching can be a isolating profession, particularly if you’re the religion teacher. Even though you’re surrounded by people all day long, you hardly have a moment to collect  your thoughts, and your colleagues are just as overworked. It’s also very draining to balance the classroom time, preparations, staff meetings, conferences, chaperoning, sponsoring activities, etc. with something resembling spiritual growth.

That’s why I really like this slim volume of reflections from fellow Catholic educators from Ave Maria Press – 5 Minutes with Christ: Spiritual Nourishment for Busy Teachers. The format is easily digestible – short essays on various snippets from the Gospels, tied to the life of a catechist and the call to discipleship. Each chapter was contributed by a graduate or associate of Notre Dame’s Alliance for Catholic Education program, which sounds like a terrific model for formation of teachers as disciples:

Because good teachers need excellent formation, ACE prepares its teachers in an innovative Master of Education program at Notre Dame, which brings them to campus for two summers of intensive training and then sends them out into classrooms during the school year…While teaching, they live in small Christian communities of four to seven members and together share the many challenges and rewards of beginning teaching…ACE teachers develop their professional skills and personal spirituality in the context of community, sharing with one another the journey of becoming committed Catholic school teachers.

What a fantastic way to prepare teachers in Catholic schools – but of course many of us come to the profession via a more circuitous route. (I myself went through a similar cohort-based program for teaching social studies, but my career as a religion teacher began after I applied for a job teaching history at a Catholic high school.) It could be that you’re teaching a section of religion on top of your primary job as a math teacher, or that you came to the classroom from another profession and are getting your formal training “on the job.”

This series of reflections by fellow teachers and administrators is a window into the experiences of your fellow religious educators, and it’s both inspiring and frank in addressing the challenges you may face.

Eighty-seven students.
Four classes to prep.
Thirty-two pages to read.
Forty-eight essays to grade.
Three parents to call.
Fourteen e-mails to reply to.

…Whether it is an issue of disrespect or someone cheating on a quiz by writing answers on the bottom of a shoe, Jesus’ call to forgive without number is a challenge. It is also a constant and often-needed reminder that students deserve forgiveness and a second chance. And, just as important on many days, it is a reminder that teachers do too.

- Beth Burau, “Forgiveness”

This is a book that could be given to all of the faculty at a Catholic school – would make a nice discussion-starter for talking about the Christian character of the school and how it relates to the day-to-day responsibilities of teachers. It’s like having a little cheering section to pick you up after a difficult day, and a spiritual director to help you focus on the deeper meaning of your relationships with your students and your role in their spiritual growth.

Highly recommended.

Disclaimer: Jared Dees, super-duper religious educator, sent me a copy of this book to preview.

Go Negative

A useful tactic to get kids to think in the classroom is to do what I call going negative.  I learned this way of thinking about a problem when I was a teenager, especially when trying to figure out faith.  Going negative isn’t new: Sherlock Holmes fans may remember how he took the same approach in asking why the dog didn’t bark. So instead of asking why Jesus did x, or why the Church teaches y, I was constantly wondering, “why didn’t Jesus do a” or “why doesn’t the Church say b.” Pondering (sometimes for years) the a,b & c that weren’t said or done often shed light on the superiority (not just the option) of x, y & z.

I churned for decades over the fundamental problem of why God required the whole Jesus project instead of simply declaring us forgiven.  God is omnipotent, after all. I suppose this is no problem for billions of Christians, but I had to grind through dozens of negative propositions to arrive at an understanding of Salvation History that meant something to me. I knew all my life that “Jesus had to die for our sins,”  but that was just a fact, like heliocentricity.  I was in my late 20s before I finally understood Jesus’ sacrifice in a way that mattered.  Oddly enough, years of “but why not…but why not…but why not…” eventually illuminated a childhood experience with a broken window which was full of “but why nots.”  Once I sorted out the broken window, faith fell into place.  I don’t think I’d've ever acquired a motivating faith without having reflected on the “why nots.”

In Catechism class the kids will sometimes make no real progress in answering a positive question, such as “why did Moses hit the rock with his staff?”  They will readily say, “God told him to;” but reader, that ain’t progress- that’s parroting. If I say, “Yes, but why did God tell him to?” I typically get, “because the people were thirsty” which is just another bit of fluff. My temptation is to give them an answer, but they can often make progress through negative questions, such as:

Why wasn’t it enough for Moses to just pray for water?
Why didn’t God make water flow from the rock without the stick business?
Why didn’t God just make the people’s thirst go away?
Why didn’t God put a lake ahead of them that they’d run into?
Why couldn’t Moses go by himself to hit the rock?

Once a couple of kids give thoughtful answers to negative questions they never heard before, we can move forward again. Within the first month of class, the kids get used to going negative when their thinking stalls. They learn to perk up each time the negative questions start, and are stimulated by the oblique thinking that negative questions engender.

Typical negative questions I might ask:

Why didn’t Jesus heal the paralyzed man as soon as he was plopped down in front of him?
Why didn’t the paralyzed man’s friends stay home and pray for his healing?
Why didn’t the Prodigal Son’s father interrupt his confession?
Why wouldn’t the Pharisees accept that Jesus had healed the blind man?
Why didn’t John the Baptist get married?
Why wouldn’t Elisha come out and speak directly to Naaman?
Why didn’t the little boy bring his bread and fish directly to Jesus?
Why didn’t Jesus and the apostles eat any lamb at the Last Supper?
Why weren’t Jesus’ wounds healed up after his Resurrection?
Why didn’t the stewards tell Jesus they had run out of wine?
Why didn’t God take more than one rib from Adam?
Why didn’t God take a toe instead of a rib?
At Mass why don’t the people put the bread and wine on the altar?

I’d give you the answers- but you’ll learn better if you work them out on your own.

Review: Be An Amazing Catechist – Sacramental Preparation

Lisa Mladinich provides clear, helpful, and uplifting support for catechists, from beginners to those looking to learn more about how to reach out to their students. Be an Amazing Catechist: Sacramental Preparation is her follow-up to her first publication, Be An Amazing Catechist. It’s an equally useful resource tailored to religious educators who are working to prepare children and adults for reception of the sacraments of initiation.

I had the honor of speaking with Lisa as she compiled suggestions for this booklet, and I can attest that she is very focused on sharing concrete tools to help catechists meet the needs of a wide variety of students. Sacramental preparation can be an especially challenging task, given that many kids show up for religious education only when it’s time to receive another sacrament, and are there at the behest of a family member but don’t attend Mass or have a basic knowledge of our faith.

The booklet provides both practical suggestions – with proper respect given for tried-and-true techniques like memorization and rote learning – and advice for how to connect with reluctant learners and inspire them to form a relationship with Christ.

Lisa manages to be encouraging without glossing over the real challenges of preparing children and adults to receive sacraments they may not fully understand when they walk in the door for that first class. In particular, her chapter on the Sacrament of Reconciliation addresses the fears and apprehension that can accompany a penitent’s first (or…subsequent) reception of the sacrament. And her advice for working with teenagers in preparation for Confirmation is genuinely optimistic and inspiring without glossing over the challenges that young adults face in today’s world.

This booklet would be a great gift for DRE’s to bestow upon their teams of catechists, either as a kickoff for the year or as encouragement once the first few classes have gone by and the needs of a particular group of students have become apparent. Slim enough to be read through in one sitting, but packed with substantive advice, it would also make a great backbone for a diocesan workshop or professional development for Catholic school teachers (because, regardless of what subject you’re teaching, you are catechizing the students.)

I highly recommend this booklet and Lisa’s first volume as well, and look forward to more of her writing! To learn more about Lisa’s motivation for writing this booklet, check out this interview with Donna Marie Cooper O’Boyle in which she talks with Lisa about her background and her hopes for how her writing can motivate those working “in the fields.”

Disclaimer: I was sent a sample copy of this book by Our Sunday Visitor.

Pitchers

I draw all the time in class.  This is a relatively tidy board, so it makes a good example of how the drawing flows along with the lesson plan.  Last night class started with some closing discussion of the Golden Calf, and finished with Samson collapsing the roof.

Here’s the board at the end of the 10/19 class; some stuff has been erased to make room for new stuff.  It’s not a very big board, so sometimes a entire board’s content has to be erased to make space for another round of picture-drawing.  I’m going to comment mostly about what’s in this picture, not the stuff that was erased.

1. The Golden Calf prodded final discussion of idol-worship, with blue squiggles showing the drunken Israelites misbehaving.  The kids knew that nobody nowadays would worship a calf statue, and suggested other types of idols that people put ahead of God.  Money was first, which led to other possessions, and ultimately to the idea of self-worship.  This led to discussing how babies only think of themselves, and that life is a process of becoming more other-oriented and less self-oriented.  During that conversation I drew a squalling baby (erased) to the upper left of the Calf, and the man on the upper right.  That was to illustrate the growth of each person from baby to adult.  I explained to the class that when I was 30 and single, I had made idols out of cars; being so self-oriented I was essentially a 30-year-old baby.

2. At this point we were discussing this handout from left to right:

Once we got into the Holy of Holies, I drew the Ark of the Covenant while reading parts of Exodus 25:

“They shall make an ark of acacia wood; two cubits and a half shall be its length, a cubit and a half its breadth, and a cubit and a half its height. 11 And you shall overlay it with pure gold… 12 And you shall cast four rings of gold for it and put them on its four feet, two rings on the one side of it, and two rings on the other side of it. 13 You shall make poles of acacia wood, and overlay them with gold. 14 And you shall put the poles into the rings on the sides of the ark, to carry the ark by them. (I don’t tell the kids what the poles are for. I make them tell me)…16 And you shall put into the ark the testimony which I shall give you. (The kids help decide what goes into the Ark, and as each item is named, I draw it in.) 17 Then you shall make a mercy seat of pure gold; two cubits and a half shall be its length, and a cubit and a half its breadth. 18 And you shall make two cherubim of gold; of hammered work shall you make them, on the two ends of the mercy seat. 19 Make one cherub on the one end, and one cherub on the other end; of one piece with the mercy seat shall you make the cherubim on its two ends. 20 The cherubim shall spread out their wings above, overshadowing the mercy seat with their wings, their faces one to another; toward the mercy seat shall the faces of the cherubim be.”

The squiggly red line indicates that God’s presence descends from Heaven to hover over the mercy seat.  To give a rough sense of scale I draw a high priest in a special outfit.

1a. Now we discussed different types of Levitical sacrifice.  To introduce the topic, I read and acted out Moses’ (pre-Levitical) sacrifice in Exodus 24:

“[Moses] rose early in the morning, and built an altar at the foot of the mountain, and twelve pillars, according to the twelve tribes of Israel. 5 And he sent young men of the people of Israel, who offered burnt offerings and sacrificed peace offerings of oxen to the LORD. 6 And Moses took half of the blood and put it in basins, and half of the blood he threw against the altar. 7 Then he took the book of the covenant, and read it in the hearing of the people; and they said, “All that the LORD has spoken we will do, and we will be obedient.” 8* And Moses took the blood and threw it upon the people, and said, “Behold the blood of the covenant which the LORD has made with you in accordance with all these words.”  We re-imagined the Golden Calf sketch as Moses’ sacrifice as I added in the blood and the basin.

3. Here we were discussing the story of Manoah and his wife, from Judges 13.  This picture illustrates the moment that the sacrifice and the angel ascend to heaven, which will figure prominently in our Eucharistic Prayer class in the Spring:

“So Manoah took the kid with the cereal offering, and offered it upon the rock to the LORD, to him who works wonders. 20 And when the flame went up toward heaven from the altar, the angel of the LORD ascended in the flame of the altar while Manoah and his wife looked on; and they fell on their faces to the ground.”

Through discussion, the kids figure out that Manoah isn’t making an atonement sacrifice for sins, but a thanksgiving sacrifice for his wife’s pregnancy.  Next week we’ll review this a bit, connect it to thanksgiving sacrifices by Abel, Melchizedek, and Moses, and introduce the Greek word Eucharisteo.

4. God had told Manoah’s wife, “Behold, you are barren and have no children; but you shall conceive and bear a son. 4 Therefore beware, and drink no wine or strong drink, and eat nothing unclean, 5 for lo, you shall conceive and bear a son. No razor shall come upon his head, for the boy shall be a Nazirite to God from birth.”  The kids figured out what “no razor shall come upon his head” implies, and then named the long-haired man that was Manoah’s son: Samson.  The kids can tell the Samson story, so I don’t need to draw.  But I do list the the things that make Samson dedicated and separated.  Next week I’ll explain what a Nazirite is, and connect that term to the concept of dedication & separation, which will repeatedly come up during the rest of the year.

Right Answer Wrong Question

In Wednesday Sunday School I try to keep the class at a low boil all the time so the kids stay energized.  There’s usually an urgency to getting fast answers to questions, and often a child will belt out a wrong answer that’s an excellent answer to a question I haven’t asked.  When possible, I will shortly follow a wrong answer with a new question that affirms that wrong answer, like so:

“Somebody remind me what happened fifty days after Easter…the Ascension!  No, that’s a good answer, though.  C’mon, fifty days after Easter…umm, Pentecost! Yes.”

And we discuss whatever was in the lesson plan about Pentecost. Then:

“Hey, speaking of stuff after Easter, what happened after forty days? Jesus went to Heaven!  Yes, which is called?  The Ascension!  Yes!”

Another example:

“Who told the Israelites that God would let bad stuff happen to the Temple just like Shiloh?  Isaiah! No, guess again.  Samuel?  Nope; this prophet also said to stop worshiping baby-eating false gods. Jeremiah!  Yes!  And who heard God call him three times?  Samuel?  There ya go.  And who said a virgin would have a baby?  Isaiah.  Yes.”

I don’t have any empirical evidence (I don’t even have quizzes) but I almost can see the open circuits closing when the kids connect an old wrong answer to a new right question.

Classroom Management

 

In Wednesday Sunday School I rarely need to admonish a child. Last week two boys were distracting each other. I walk over to where they are engaged in footplay, wait for ‘em to notice me. They look up. I put on a quizzical expression and ask, “Are y’all flirting?”

End of problem.

Next week my Faithful Bouncer will separate them.

Catechist Chat: Word Clouds

Word clouds – those artistic arrangements of words within a chunk of text – are a fun, visual way to capture the content of what you’re reading.

We see them on blogs as “tag clouds,” automatically generated displays of terms that highlight the most frequently used words. Sr. Caroline Cerveny of A Cyberpilgrim’s Blog shared a twist on the idea – creating Word Clouds from prayers:

Our Father Word Cloud

Sr. Caroline provides several clever ways to integrate Word Clouds into classroom discussions – she is really one of the most tech-savvy people I know, in terms of actually coming up with ways to utilize digital tools.

One thing we both noticed is that the automatically-generated Word Clouds do not understand which words are the most “important” parts of the text, although I’m sure there are ways to tweak that – so the default result emphasizes words like “thy” which show up most frequently but are probably not most important.

A low-tech activity along these lines would be to have students create Word Clouds on a slightly older technology: posterboard. Here’s how I would go about doing so:

  • Group the students in pairs or teams of 3.
  • Give each team the chunk of text and a pair of scissors, or go ahead and print up several sets of cards with the words of the prayer/text on them. Here’s a sample set for the Our Father (click on the image to be taken to a printable PDF Our Father set of cards.)Activity for learning the Our Father
  • Give the teams about 10 minutes to arrange a “word cloud” on the floor, a desktop, etc. They should discuss which words should be featured most prominently in the Word Cloud and how they’ll do so.
  • Have them spend another 15-20 minutes creating Word Cloud posters that emphasize those particular words via brighter colors, larger writing, etc.
  • End by having each group present their Word Cloud to the class and explain how they decided which words to feature.

I really like having kids work with text that they can move around physically – it helps get the attention of those tactile-kinisthetic learners (translation: fidgety kids) and also gives them a concrete way to move things around and think about where they should go.

I like to do this, myself, when I am trying to put together an outline based on lots of different sources of text. Add the visual dimension of creating the Word Cloud and the discussion with their peers about which words should go where, and you have provided a rich opportunity to really tease apart the meaning of a prayer.

You could do this with any selection of text, really, but I would think a necessary prerequisite would be for the students to already be fairly familiar with the text.

And, needless to say, you’ll have to monitor the discussions to make sure you don’t end up with smarty-pants who decide to put “THE” front and center.

Christian LeBlanc

Christian LeBlanc is a revert whose pre-Vatican II childhood was spent in South Louisiana, where he marinated in a Catholic universe and acquired a Catholic imagination. During his middle school years in South Carolina, Christian was catechized under the benevolent dictatorship of Sister Mary Alphonsus, who frequently admonished him using the nickname “Little Pagan.” After four years of teaching Adult Ed and RCIA, he returned to Sr. Alphonsus’ old classroom to teach sixth grade Catechism himself. This is his seventh year teaching sixth grade. Married to Janet, the LeBlancs have five children and two grandsons. Christian and Janet belong to St. Mary’s parish in Greenville, South Carolina. In affectionate tribute to Sr. Alphonsus, his column is entitled “Little Pagans.”

View Christian’s recent columns.

Contact Christian at CHRISLEB1@aol.com.


Warning: call_user_func_array() [function.call-user-func-array]: First argument is expected to be a valid callback, 'wpfbogp_end_ob' was given in /home/amazing/public_html/wp-includes/plugin.php on line 405